739. The Simple Gratitude System That Doubled Donor Retention (From 33% to 66%) - April Thompson
Listen to this episode
About This Episode
In 2021, April Thompson became the first development staff member at Olympic Angels, a grassroots foster care nonprofit on the rural Olympic Peninsula with about 100 donors. Four years later, the donor file had passed 400, recurring gifts had tripled, and donor retention had doubled from 33% to 66% — against national benchmarks closer to 24%.
What moved the number wasn't a campaign. It was a gratitude system simple enough to run every single time: a personal voicemail within 48 hours, a handwritten card from a board member days later, and a story reported back. In this episode of Possible in Practice, April walks through exactly how it works.
In this episode, you'll hear:
The "one-two punch" gratitude guide that doubled retention, and how to document it so nobody loses track of the last donor touch
Why a ringless voicemail drop is the highest-return, lowest-lift gratitude tool most small shops have never tried
How to batch and schedule 10–15 personal thank-you messages at a time, so gratitude runs on a cadence instead of on your memory
If you've been waiting for a bigger budget to fix your retention numbers, April's answer is a lot simpler and starts this week. 🩵
Episode Highlights:
(2:43) April's path: hotel galas, animal shelters, and learning on her feet
(4:42) Fractional fundraising before it had a name
(6:04) The case study: 33% to 66% with a team of one
(7:54) The single most effective tool in her toolbox
(10:14) Batching gratitude and recapturing failed recurring gifts
(12:08) Voicemail drops in a year-end campaign
(13:54) The gratitude guide: the "one-two punch" system
(14:56) Start with the capacity you actually have
(16:19) A moment of philanthropy: founders
(17:49) One good thing: giving gratitude is never time wasted
Meet April: The Fundraiser Who Turned Gratitude Into a System
April Thompson is a fractional development consultant with Threadwell Consulting, working with small social service nonprofits across the U.S. from her home just south of Barcelona. She has spent more than a decade inside nonprofits turning good intentions into repeatable practice — most notably at Olympic Angels, where systematizing gratitude doubled donor retention. April believes fundraising should create more capacity for mission, not more overwhelm. Find her on LinkedIn or at april@threadwellconsulting.com.
Powerful Quotes
"Giving gratitude is never time wasted." — Susan Howlett, quoted by April
"It's a low lift, high return tool and practice. It's been met with nothing but praise from donors." — April
"I'm very charming and warm, and I say their real name with my real human voice, with all of my uh's and ums left in." — April
"Being human builds trust with you and the relationship you're building with the donor and with the organization." — April
"This is just another tool for leaders to use to give gratitude at scale." — April
"I advise calling everyone, every single one, even the $5 ones, because that's a perfect example of philanthropy being democratized." — April
"I attribute a lot of that to consistency. Just figuring out what you have the capacity to do, finding the right tools and practices." — April
"Surprise and delight your people, and they will sustain your mission." — April
Resources Mentioned
Threadwell Consulting: April's fractional development consulting practice, serving small social service nonprofits
Olympic Angels: foster care nonprofit on the rural Olympic Peninsula, part of the National Angels network, where April built the retention system
National Angels: the national network Olympic Angels belongs to
Sly Broadcast: ringless voicemail delivery platform April used for one-to-one donor gratitude; she notes she has no affiliation with the company
Unreasonable Hospitality by Will Guidara: the book April says every development officer should read
Susan Howlett: April's nonprofit management professor, source of "giving gratitude is never time wasted"
April on LinkedIn: where she posts regular, actionable fundraising nuggets
april@threadwellconsulting.com: direct email
Come join us in the We Are For Good Community!
Join fellow changemakers, share takeaways from this episode, and keep collaborating in a space built for connection, inspiration, and real impact: www.weareforgoodcommunity.com
Say hi👇
LinkedIn / Instagram / Facebook / YouTube
